登陆注册
23990700000039

第39章 Cloning: Good Science or Baaa ad Idea(1)

Ⅰ. Reading Str ategy: Dist ingu ishing Fa ct fr om Opinion

Facts and opinions are both used by a writer to support the main idea of a piece ofwriting. In order to attain a higher level of comprehension,you should acquire theability to distinguish facts from opinions in reading. With this ability,you can readcritically,so that you will not accept everything you read as fact.

A fact is a statement that can be proven true through objective evidence such asobservation or experimentation. It is also defined as something that actually exists,orthat everyone agrees is true. But it should be noticed that there are true facts and falsefacts . For example,the statement the sun moved around the ear th is obviously a falsefact as it has long been proven wrong.

An opinion,on the other hand,is a statement that cannot be objectively proventrue or false. It usually refers to one??s personal belief,feeling or judgment aboutsomething. An opinion,therefore,is open to debate even if it is based on fact. Thereare words that can serve as clues to statements of opinion. For example,words like Ibelieve,I think,in my opinion,I feel,and I suggest,show clearly that an opinionwill follow. Words like proba bly,perhaps,usua lly,often,sometimes,and onoccasion,are used to indicate the possibility of other opinions. Besides,opinionstatements usually have“ qualifier words”which represent opinions. Some of suchwords are: best,worst,great,ter rible,and wonder ful. However,looking for cluewords is far from enough for you to keep opinions from facts,as sometimes opinionsmay be masked as facts,which means they can be written so that they appear to befacts. This is especially true when someone is quoted. For example,Paul Freiberger,a technology expert,is quoted in Fuzzy Logic Sma rt Machines as follows: “ It??s atechnology that will change forever the way we deal with machines. ”This is just thespeaker??s opinion,one that would be shared by some people but not likely by all. Aquotation does not necessarily make a statement a fact. If a quotation is a fact,then itscontent must be factual. For example,you are dealing with a fact when Zadeh,acomputer science professor says in the same piece of writing,“ Computers dependupon exact information to do their work. We don??t. ”

Ⅱ. Applying the Read ing Str ategy

In this part,you are required to use the reading strategy you have just learned.

Read the following statements and decide whether they are facts or opinions.

1. The use of the motorcar is becoming more and more widespread in the twentiethcentury.

2. The feeling of independence,and the freedom to go where you please,is perhapsthe greatest advantage of the car .

3. Television is a great time-waster .

4. Television encourages passive enjoyment.

5. According to the August 10th issue of The Youth,out of 30,000 school graduatesin Shanghai who could take the college entrance examination this year ,only 23,000 sat for it.

6. There is not much point in going to college anyway because you can hardly everget an ideal job after you graduate.

7. Statistics show that rapid population growth creates problems for developingcountries.

8. It is only when people??s living standards begin to rise that birth rates begin to fall.

9. The housing reform gives the rich minority rather than the average majority achance to live better.

10. Vacant buildings ought to be turned into apartment buildings for the homeless.

Ⅲ. Reading Task

A. Pr e-r eading act ivity

Since the announcement of the birth of Dolly,the first mammal cloned from anadult cell,the fierce debate revolving around the issue of cloning a human being hasgreatly expanded. After being diagnosed with progressive lung disease,Dolly??s lifewas taken to an end by her creators. Her relatively early death in February 2003 fuelsthe debate. What??s your attitude towards human cloning? Do you think if scientistswill succeed in cloning a human in the near future in spite of people??s objections? Doyou agree or disagree that it??s worth the risk to clone a human being?

B. Reading

Prepare for disaster . That was the level of pessimism when veterinary researchersJonathan Hill and Mark Westhusin got ready to deliver the world??s first cloned bull atTexas A &M University a year and a half ago. And the scientists had good reason tobe pessimistic: several years of animal cloning work had taught them that most clonedanimals never even make it to birth,and the rare ones that do all too frequently haveproblems ranging from physical deformities to life-threatening medical conditions.This cream-colored calf,named Second Chance,was no exception.“ In his firstweek he was near death,” recalls Hill. He had underdeveloped lungs,like apremature baby. He had diabetes,anemia,a skin infection,and so many othercomplications that Hill can??t even recall them all. The calf spent his first few dayshooked up to intensive care machines.

Today,Second Chance grazes serenely in a pasture outside Austin,to allappearances just one more healthy bull in the herd. But if Second Chance??s healthproblems are behind him,many other animal clones have not fared so well. Indeed,the catalog of illnesses in cloned animals includes everything from blood vesselabnormalities and fatty livers to weak immune systems and deformed heads.

Such are the perils of taking cloning out of agricultural research labs and intofertility clinics. What if instead of Second Chance it had been a human baby hookedup to those life support machines? What if the baby had never recovered from thehealth problems,or indeed had died as many cloned animals do? The fierce debateover human cloning shifted from theoretical moral objections to practical safetyconcerns last week as researchers gathered in Italy for the first serious scientificmeeting devoted to human cloning.

Last week??s conference was organized by two experts with experience in cuttingedgereproductive technology; Panos Zavos,who runs a fertility clinic in Lexington,Ky. ,and Italian fertility doctor Severino Antinori. They plan to clone a human withintwo years,and many scientists don??t doubt that they??ll succeed.

同类推荐
  • 生活英语会话想说就会说

    生活英语会话想说就会说

    看到26个字母就鸭梨山大?还是在死磕“哑巴英语”?别担心,本书将生活和英语结合起来,让您在生活中轻轻松松学习英语。其中内容涉及生话英语交流中的各种典型场景。从爱情婚姻、生活起居、购物天地,食全食美、家庭理财、医院就医、家庭汽车、谈天说地和社会问题等方面来展现生活休闲过程中的各种真实情景,所选题材齐全,语言简洁明快,易学好记,实用性强。
  • 八月之光

    八月之光

    女主人公丽娜·格罗夫,一个即将临盆的姑娘千里寻夫抵达杰佛生镇(福克纳以家乡密西西比州拉菲叶县为原型虚构的小镇),老父病故,丽娜唯一的亲人哥嫂一家也因其尴尬处境将她拒之门外;而丽娜费尽周折所要寻找的卢卡斯?伯奇不过是个无足轻重的骗子,他正极力躲避姑娘的追寻。小说的另一线索是作为白人居住在杰佛生镇的乔?克里斯默斯因奸杀白人老处女乔安娜·伯顿,他身上所具有的黑人血统已逐渐败露,终于惨遭屠戮。
  • 双语学习丛书-摩登口语

    双语学习丛书-摩登口语

    流淌心灵的隽语,记忆的箴言,在双语的世界里,感受英语学习的乐趣,体会英语学习的奥妙,提高英语学习的能力!丛书包括:爱的交融、财富精英、成长课堂、醇香母爱、父爱如山、故乡情怀、节日趣闻、快乐心语、浪漫往昔等故事。
  • 飘(英文原版)

    飘(英文原版)

    《飘》是美国有名作家玛格丽特·米切尔的长篇小说。1937年,她因本书获得普利策奖,1949年,她在车祸中罹难。她短暂的一生并未留下太多的作品,但只一部?GONE?WITH?THE?WIND?足以奠定她在世界文学史中不可动摇的地位。本书讲述的故事是:美国南北战争摧毁了佐治亚乃至整个南方的经济,黑奴重新获得自由,昔日奴隶主养尊处优的好时光随风而逝,飘得远远的。为了生存,他们必须放下臭架子,努力奋斗,不然只有死路一条,连亚兰大上流社会的中坚分子也不得不降贵屈尊,卖糕饼的卖糕饼,赶马车的赶马车。生动再现了美国佐治亚州在内战及重建时期的情形,传神地刻画出在传统社会崩溃瓦解时,人们如何应付这场社会巨变的艰辛过程。?小说《飘》在战争的背景下,道出了战争对人类心灵的影响。
  • 英语PARTY——蓝色天堂·意大利

    英语PARTY——蓝色天堂·意大利

    本套书籍带你领略英语世界风景,感悟英语学习氛围,有助于英语学习。
热门推荐
  • 主宰万千

    主宰万千

    善与恶,毁灭与创造,修罗血脉,一切的一切都汇集在一人身上,且看他如何称霸万千
  • 天行

    天行

    号称“北辰骑神”的天才玩家以自创的“牧马冲锋流”战术击败了国服第一弓手北冥雪,被誉为天纵战榜第一骑士的他,却受到小人排挤,最终离开了效力已久的银狐俱乐部。是沉沦,还是再次崛起?恰逢其时,月恒集团第四款游戏“天行”正式上线,虚拟世界再起风云!
  • 残疾老公宠妻

    残疾老公宠妻

    一场车祸,他的人生有了翻天覆地的变化。成了一个一无用处的废人,令他痛苦不堪。而现在,那个最疼爱他的爷爷,为了要一个继承人,竟然随便找一个女人跟他生孩子?女人,你小心了,他可不会怜香惜玉。
  • 陌若浮生:四生情四世劫

    陌若浮生:四生情四世劫

    那是一个深秋,秋雨瑟瑟,血红的枫叶铺了满地。落叶下,隐藏的,却是某些不为人知的秘密。汩汩的血液蔓延满地…她和哥哥父母双亡,被路过的三对富豪夫妻所救。带回家中,二个月后三对夫妻无故失踪。长大后她开始追查父母奇怪的死因,发现杀死父母的仇人竟是自己几个同吃同住的哥哥的父母!愤怒,迷茫,心痛下,她却发现…真相另有隐情……爱情,友情,背叛,恨意互相交织,为你展现出一个女孩的爱恨情仇。
  • 清秋未迟月向晚

    清秋未迟月向晚

    命运翻云覆雨的手啊,从不肯放过任何一个可怜人。当你眼见着赖以存活的温暖被一丝丝搅碎,当你被仇恨蒙住双眼,被拖进污泥与血水的深渊,是否还能看见,遥远的,爱人眼底的光亮?当你完完全全被痛苦淹没,只要还活着,就是重生。爱恨匆匆的尽头,命运轮盘已缓缓转动。
  • 三国杀传奇之窃玉偷香

    三国杀传奇之窃玉偷香

    刘章平静的生活被轻易打破,身边突然出现的神秘人大义凛然的给他带来一大波妹子,作为极品宅男的刘章童鞋还真有些把持不住。但他自己却真诚说道:“作为一个绝品好男人,是绝对不能做出引诱妇女的可耻行为。”
  • 溺宠星际小魔女

    溺宠星际小魔女

    众人眼中的废物小姐?被放弃流放异族星球?尹贝贝表示这和她有什么关系,自己不过得好好的。但是……这里异族一次次的试探她,真的很烦人啊,想找个安稳地儿都难。——异族大军集体表示,它们是在怕你打击它们啊……忍不住换个地,可为什么出去一次还带回了一个男人?尹贝贝有点懵逼。不过,好像也挺好的,有个人啥都替你办的妥妥的,自己的小日子貌似过得更舒服了哦?小剧情(一):“二长老!不好了!……咱的货被独眼海盗团给劫了!”诺大的会议室里充斥着惊慌失措的声音,来人满头大汗的看着坐在首位的老者。“怎么可能!我们一向和他们无怨,他们竟无视星际法律!”二长老纵然老谋深算,也没料到有这种事。“听……听说大小姐和独眼老大关系很好……”突然,一句小心翼翼的话传来,本来躁乱的地方顿时静了下来。小剧情(二):“宝……贝贝,要不要去星月星球玩玩?”俊美的男人正儿八经的坐在沙发上,看着对面沙发上窝着的少女道,眼里充满期待。少女放下书,抬眼看了看他,“你无聊?”男人无言以对,难道告白计划又要失败了?男人皱眉思索,一脸无奈。?本文轻松,脑洞比较大,喜欢的就收藏收藏看看叭~★勿转、勿喷哦。
  • 盏琉璃

    盏琉璃

    在天帝寿宴时,各路神仙亲眼目睹火神怀中娇滴滴的小娘子,而这小娘子只是个不出名的贝壳精。
  • 快穿追妻之冷漠男神请退离

    快穿追妻之冷漠男神请退离

    (一对一)娇软绵绵的炎锦写了一本厚厚的追夫攻略36计,完成之际,突现一个系统需要她去攻略她所写的三十六种男神好感值,飞来横事,她只能见招拆招?
  • 穿越后我收了小弟

    穿越后我收了小弟

    宋浔穿越了,因为一个棺!材!她表示:穿越就算了,你给我送到这个鸟不拉屎的地方干什么?玩吗?宋浔