(September 1831)
The Life of Samuel Johnson LL.D.Including a Journal Of a Tour to the Hebrides by James Boswell, Esq.A new Edition, with numerous Additions and Notes By JOHN WILSON CROKER, LL.D., F.R.S.
Five volumes, 8vo.London: 1831
THIS work has greatly disappointed us.Whatever faults we may have been prepared to find in it, we fully expected that it would be a valuable addition to English literature; that it would contain many curious facts, and many judicious remarks; that the style of the notes would be neat, clear, and precise; and that the typographical execution would be, as in new editions of classical works it ought to be, almost faultless.We are sorry to be obliged to say that the merits of Mr.Croker's performance are on a par with those of a certain leg of mutton on which Dr.
Johnson dined, while travelling from London to Oxford, and which he, with characteristic energy, pronounced to be "as bad as bad could be, ill fed, ill killed, ill kept, and ill dressed." This edition is ill compiled, ill arranged, ill written, and ill printed.
Nothing in the work has astonished us so much as the ignorance or carelessness of Mr.Croker with respect to facts and dates.Many of his blunders are such as we should be surprised to hear any well-educated gentleman commit, even in conversation.The notes absolutely swarm with misstatements, into which the editor never would have fallen, if he had taken the slightest pains to investigate the truth of his assertions, or if he had even been well acquainted with the book on which he undertook to comment.
We will give a few instances.
Mr.Croker tells us in a note that Derrick, who was master of the ceremonies at Bath, died very poor in 1760.[Vol.i.394.] We read on; and, a few pages later, we find Dr.Johnson and Boswell talking of this same Derrick as still living and reigning, as having retrieved his character, as possessing so much power over his subjects at Bath, that his opposition might be fatal to Sheridan's lectures on oratory.[i.404.] And all this is in 1763.The fact is, that Derrick died in 1769.
In one note we read, that Sir Herbert Croft, the author of that pompous and foolish account of Young, which appears among the Lives of the Poets, died in 1805.[Vol.iv.321.] Another note in the same volume states, that this same Sir Herbert Croft died at Paris, after residing abroad for fifteen years, on the 27th of April, 1816.[iv.428.]
Mr.Croker informs us, that Sir William Forbes of Pitsligo, the author of the Life of Beattie, died in 1816.[ii.262.] A Sir William Forbes undoubtedly died in that year, but not the Sir William Forbes in question, whose death took place in 1806.It is notorious, indeed, that the biographer of Beattie lived just long enough to complete the history of his friend.Eight or nine years before the date which Mr.Croker has assigned for Sir William's death, Sir Walter Scott lamented that event in the introduction to the fourth canto of Marmion.Every schoolgirl knows the lines:
"Scarce had lamented Forbes paid The tribute to his Minstrel's shade;The tale of friendship scarce was told, Ere the narrator's heart was cold:
Far may we search before we find A heart so manly and so kind!"In one place, we are told, that Allan Ramsay, the painter, was born in 1709, and died in 1784; [iv.105.] in another, that he died in 1784, in the seventy-first year of his age.[v.281.]
In one place, Mr.Croker says, that at the commencement of the intimacy between Dr.Johnson and Mrs.Thrale, in 1765, the lady was twenty-five years old.[i.510.] In other places he says, that Mrs.Thrale's thirty-fifth year coincided with Johnson's seventieth.[iv.271, 322.] Johnson was born in 1709.If, therefore, Mrs.Thrale's thirty-fifth year coincided with Johnson's seventieth, she could have been only twenty-one years old in 1765.This is not all.Mr.Croker, in another place, assigns the year 1777 as the date of the complimentary lines which Johnson made on Mrs.Thrale's thirty-fifth birthday.
[iii.463.] If this date be correct, Mrs.Thrale must have been born in 1742, and could have been only twenty-three when her acquaintance with Johnson commenced.Mr.Croker therefore gives us three different statements as to her age.Two of the three must be incorrect.We will not decide between them; we will only say, that the reasons which Mr.Croker gives for thinking that Mrs.Thrale was exactly thirty-five years old when Johnson was seventy, appear to us utterly frivolous.
Again, Mr.Croker informs his readers that "Lord Mansfield survived Johnson full ten years." [ii.151.] Lord Mansfield survived Dr.Johnson just eight years and a quarter.
Johnson found in the library of a French lady, whom he visited during his short visit to Paris, some works which he regarded with great disdain."I looked," says he, "into the books in the lady's closet, and, in contempt, showed them to Mr.Thrale.
Prince Titi, Bibliotheque des Fees, and other books." [iii.271.]
